White Fillings vs. Silver Fillings: Which Is Better for Your Smile in San Juan Capistrano?

San Juan Capistrano, CA


When it comes to treating cavities, most patients today want restorations that are strong, durable, and invisible. That’s why one of the most common questions we hear at Kaban Dental Group in San Juan Capistrano is:

“Are white fillings really better than silver ones?”

The answer depends on your goals, the tooth being restored, and your long-term dental health priorities. Here’s how composite (white) fillings compare with amalgam (silver) fillings—and how to decide what’s right for you.


What Are White (Composite) Fillings?

White fillings, also known as tooth-colored or composite fillings, are made from a blend of resin and finely ground glass particles. They bond directly to your tooth structure, offering a natural appearance that blends seamlessly with your smile.

Advantages:

  • Aesthetic—matches the color of your natural teeth

  • Bonds directly to enamel for added strength

  • Requires less drilling and preserves more healthy tooth

  • Mercury-free and biocompatible

Ideal for: Front teeth, visible areas, and small- to medium-sized cavities.

Learn more about Fillings in San Juan Capistrano.

What Are Silver (Amalgam) Fillings?

Silver fillings—made from a mixture of silver, tin, copper, and mercury—have been used safely for decades. They’re known for their durability and ability to withstand heavy chewing forces.

Advantages:

  • Extremely strong and long-lasting (10–15+ years)

  • Less expensive than composite materials

  • Effective for large cavities in back molars

Drawbacks:

  • Visible metallic color—noticeable when you laugh or talk

  • May darken the surrounding tooth structure

  • Requires more tooth removal to fit securely

  • Contains a small amount of mercury (though stabilized in the alloy)

Aesthetics vs. Durability—Finding the Right Balance

For many San Juan Capistrano patients, the decision comes down to where the filling is located:

  • Front teeth: White fillings blend beautifully and maintain a natural look.

  • Back molars: Silver fillings are more affordable and can endure chewing pressure, though modern composites have improved in durability.

At Kaban Dental Group, we often recommend composite materials for most patients because today’s options are both strong and cosmetic—ideal for South OC patients seeking long-term protection and confidence in their smile.

Can I Replace My Old Silver Fillings?

Yes! Many patients choose to replace older amalgam fillings for cosmetic reasons or if the metal has started to corrode. The process involves safely removing the silver filling and replacing it with a custom-shaded composite resin that matches your natural tooth color.

Learn more:

Cost Comparison in San Juan Capistrano

White (Composite)

Composite Fillings

Average Cost / Tooth
$180 – $300
Lifespan
~7–12 years
Aesthetic
Tooth-colored, blends naturally
Ideal Use
Front teeth & small–medium cavities

Bonded to enamel; preserves more healthy tooth structure.

Silver (Amalgam)

Amalgam Fillings

Average Cost / Tooth
$150 – $250
Lifespan
~10–15 years
Aesthetic
Metallic; visible when smiling
Ideal Use
Back molars & high-bite-force areas

Very durable; may require more tooth removal and won’t match tooth color.

Which Is Better for You?

If you’re seeking a natural look and conservative treatment, white composite fillings are typically best.
If you prioritize maximum strength and lower cost, silver fillings may still be a practical option.

During your visit, our dental team will evaluate the size, position, and stress level on the tooth to recommend the most effective restoration for long-term success.

H2: Local Expertise You Can Trust

At Kaban Dental Group, we combine precision, modern materials, and local experience to ensure your fillings look natural and last. Whether you’re in San Juan Capistrano, Dana Point, Mission Viejo, or San Clemente, our restorative and cosmetic care is tailored to your smile.

📞 Call (949) 496-5585 or schedule an appointment online for an evaluation today.

Dr. Kelly Kaban

Dr. Kelly Kaban graduated from the University of California, Berkeley with her Bachelor of Science degree in Molecular Environmental Biology and graduated from Loma Linda University School of Dentistry with honors in 2017.

Dr. Kaban infuses learning, nature, and fitness as ways to bring balance and peace of mind to her life.

https://www.kabandentalgroup.com/
Previous
Previous

Do Cavities Always Need Fillings? Early Decay Treatment Options in South OC

Next
Next

Tooth Filling Coming Loose? What to Do Before Seeing a Dentist in San Juan Capistrano